NRSG 3883-01 Nursing Research: Qualitative Critical Appraisal

NRSG 3883-01 Nursing Research: Qualitative Critical Appraisal

Qualitative Critical Appraisal: [Insert Study Title]

[First & Last Name]

East Central University, School of Nursing

NRSG 3883-01 Nursing Research

[date]

Qualitative Critical Appraisal

[Type the introduction in this section. Include a brief summary of the qualitative study being appraised, a statement of purpose for the appraisal, and identification of the study design (e.g., phenomenology, ethnography, grounded theory). Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Evaluation of the Study Components

Title and Abstract

[Summarize the clarity and specificity of the title and the inclusion of purpose, sample, methods, and key findings in the abstract in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Problem Statement and Purpose

[Summarize the significance and relevance to nursing, background information provided, clarity of the research problem, and stated research objectives/questions in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Literature Review

[Summarize the relevance and currency of references, the theoretical framework or philosophical foundation, and identification of research gaps in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Methodological Appraisal

Sampling

[Summarize the sampling method (e.g., purposive, convenience), inclusion/exclusion criteria, and the sample size and appropriateness for study goals in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Ethical Considerations

[Summarize IRB/ethics review and informed consent process in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Data Collection

[Summarize data collection methods (interviews, focus groups, observations, documents), adequacy of data in terms of richness and depth, and researcher-participant relationship in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Data Management and Analysis

[Summarize data recording and handling, use of coding, themes, and participant quotes, and consistency with study design and research question in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Results and Interpretation

Presentation of Results

[Summarize description of participants, use of themes/concepts, supporting data, and alignment with qualitative methodology in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Discussion

[Summarize significant findings and their implications, limitations, transferability, and relevance to practice and future research in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Appraisal of Study Quality

Strengths and Weaknesses

[Summarize the strength of alignment between purpose, methodology, and findings, and critical evaluation of study rigor, depth, and clarity in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

Trustworthiness and Credibility

[Summarize participant voice authenticity, thoroughness of research process, and the confidence of the findings in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]Conclusion

[Summarize the overall study quality, contribution to nursing knowledge or practice, and personal evaluation of the study’s impact in this section. Use the current in-text APA citation.]

References

Last Name, F. M. (Year). Article Title. Journal Title, Vol.(Issue), pp. From – To.

Nursing_research

Dissecting Through the Literature: A Review of the Critical Appraisal Process – PMC